Looking for Christmas cookie tray ideas? This collection brings together chewy cookies, frosted bars, chocolate bark, homemade candy, and no-bake treats you can mix and match for holiday parties or gift boxes. You’ll also find two edible centerpiece ideas for a larger dessert table.
A mix of baked and no-bake recipes helps spread out the prep when your oven is busy. If you want to start with something simple, try the Biscoff Chocolate Quinoa Clusters or No-Bake Gingerbread Truffles, then add a favorite cookie recipe.These cookies are easy to make, look festive on any dessert table, and make the sweetest homemade gifts.
Biscoff Toffee Crack
My #1 requested recipe! Crunchy Biscoff cookies are covered with buttery Biscoff toffee and a smooth chocolate layer, then finished with crushed cookies. Break the chilled slab into smaller pieces to add a crisp, caramel-flavored treat to your tray. Allow time for it to set before packing.
Check out this recipe
Easy Hot Cocoa Marshmallow Fluff Stuffed Cookies
These thick chocolate cookies are filled with white, milk, and dark chocolate chunks, then piped with marshmallow fluff after baking, with the option to make your own homemade fluff. They bring soft centers and gooey marshmallow filling to a Christmas cookie tray. Let them cool and firm up before arranging them.
Check out this recipe
Christmas Reindeer Crack Toffee (Easy Saltine Toffee Recipe for Kids)
Saltine crackers, buttery toffee, and melted chocolate form the base for these reindeer treats. Pretzel antlers, candy eyes, and candy noses add the Christmas decorations. The toffee uses the stovetop and oven, with decorating done while the chocolate is still soft.
Check out this recipe
Peppermint Patty Stuffed Dates (Easy, No-Bake Recipe)
These Peppermint Patty Stuffed Dates have a creamy peppermint filling tucked inside soft Medjool dates and a crisp dark chocolate coating. They have the chocolate and mint flavor of a peppermint patty, with a soft, chewy center from the dates.
Check out this recipe
Easy 5-Ingredient Biscoff Chocolate Quinoa Clusters (No Bake Candy Recipe)
Puffed quinoa and crushed Biscoff cookies give these chocolate clusters their crunch, while cookie butter holds everything together with the melted chocolate. Scoop them onto parchment and let them set. They're a useful no-bake option when your oven is already full.
Check out this recipe
Easy, Homemade Vanilla Bean Marshmallows
These homemade marshmallows are soft and fluffy, with vanilla bean flavor and a light powdered sugar coating. Add a few to your tray in a paper baking cup, or package them alongside hot cocoa. Plan ahead so they have time to set before cutting.
Check out this recipe
Chocolate Peppermint Protein Balls (Refined Sugar-Free, No Bake, High Protein, Vegan)
Dates, almond butter, cocoa, and chocolate protein powder make the soft chocolate centers of these no-bake peppermint balls. A white baking chip coating and crushed candy canes add a peppermint bark finish. Store them chilled and add a small batch to your tray at serving time.
Check out this recipe
Gluten-Free Christmas Crack Date Bark
Chewy Medjool dates are layered with coconut sugar toffee and chocolate, then topped with crushed pretzels, crackers, and flaky salt. The combination adds sweet-and-salty crunch to your tray. Keep the bark chilled according to the recipe's storage directions.
Check out this recipe
No-Bake Gingerbread Truffles
These no-bake gingerbread truffles have a soft, spiced center made with oats, dates, nut butter, and gingerbread spices, finished with a white chocolate coating. Make them ahead and keep them chilled until you're ready to serve. Paper baking cups help keep the coating tidy on the tray.
Check out this recipe
Authentic Cannoli Filling Recipe with Chocolate Chips and Pistachios
Fill store-bought cannoli shells with this creamy ricotta and mascarpone filling or break the shells into pieces and use it as a dip in your cookie tray.
Check out this recipe
Nutella Stuffed Kinder Bueno Cookies
These thick cookies have a creamy Nutella center, chopped Kinder chocolate, Kinder Bueno, and white chocolate chips. A piece of Kinder Bueno on top makes them easy to spot on a tray. Allow for the filling and dough chilling steps when planning your baking.
Check out this recipe
Baileys Chocolate Protein Truffles (Easy No-Bake Recipe)
These Baileys Protein Truffles are rich, chocolatey, and packed with Baileys flavor. Made with simple ingredients and a boost of protein, they have a soft, fudgy texture that makes them perfect for an easy sweet treat. They're simple to make, require no baking, and are great for holiday dessert trays, parties, or keeping in the fridge when you want something chocolatey.
Check out this recipe
Protein Sugar Cookie Bars (Refined Sugar Free, Gluten Free)
Soft almond flour sugar cookie bars are topped with creamy frosting made with cream cheese, Greek yogurt, and protein powder. Bake them in one pan, then slice into smaller squares for sharing. Keep the frosted bars refrigerated and add sprinkles close to serving.
Check out this recipe
Healthy Twix Bars with Date Caramel
These homemade Twix bars have a tender almond flour base, a thick layer of chewy date caramel, and a dark chocolate topping. Cut the chilled bars into smaller pieces for your Christmas tray or a refrigerated gift box. They add a cookie-caramel-chocolate combination to the mix.
Check out this recipe
Healthy Samoa Cookies (Vegan, No Sugar Added)
Toasted coconut, dates, and tahini give these no-bake cookies their chewy texture and caramel-like flavor. A chocolate base and drizzle finish them off. Add them to your selection for a coconut option, and follow the recipe's directions for chilled storage.
Check out this recipe
Healthy Peppermint Sugar Cookie Bars (Refined Sugar Free, Gluten Free, High Protein)
These peppermint sugar cookie bars have a soft, chewy base and creamy peppermint frosting. They’re an easy holiday bake with no rolling or cookie cutters needed. Finish with crushed candy canes for a little extra peppermint crunch.
Check out this recipe
Espresso Martini Brownies
These fudgy chocolate brownies combine espresso flavor with Kahlúa and Frangelico in both the brownies and frosting. Cut them into small squares for an adult holiday dessert tray. Label them clearly so guests know they contain alcohol and coffee.
Check out this recipe
Gingerbread Christmas Crack Date Bark (Easy No-Bake Holiday Treat!)
Chewy Medjool dates are layered with spiced coconut sugar caramel, melted chocolate, and crunchy gingerbread cookie pieces. Molasses and gingerbread spices give this bark its holiday flavor. Make it ahead, chill until set, and cut into small pieces for serving.
Check out this recipe
Coconut Sugar Chocolate Chip Cookies with Brown Butter
These coconut sugar chocolate chip cookies have soft, chewy centers, lightly crisp edges, and rich brown butter flavor. They add a familiar cookie to a tray of peppermint, gingerbread, and candy treats. Bake a batch for gift boxes or a plate to leave out for Santa with some milk.
Check out this recipe
Snickers Date Bark with Crunchy Quinoa
The viral Snickers bark. Chocolate, crunchy quinoa, chewy dates, peanut butter, chopped peanuts, and more chocolate. Cut it into small pieces to share the chocolate-peanut combination across your tray. Keep it chilled as directed in the recipe.
Check out this recipe
Mini Egg Chocolate Chip Cookies
These thick chocolate chip cookies are filled with chopped Mini Eggs for a mix of chocolate and candy-shell crunch. A holiday variation idea is to try red and green candy-coated chocolates in place of the Mini Eggs.
Check out this recipe
BONUS CENTERPIECE RECIPE: Santa Buttercream Frosting Board
Create Santa's face with buttercream, then surround it with cookies, pretzels, marshmallows, and other small treats for dipping. Use this as the center of a larger dessert table, with your cookie trays nearby. Add the dippers close to serving so they stay crisp.
Check out this recipe
BONUS CENTERPIECE RECIPE: Easy Biscoff Puff Pastry Christmas Tree
Layers of puff pastry and Biscoff spread are shaped into a Christmas tree with twisted branches people can pull apart. The pastry bakes into a flaky centerpiece with a cookie butter filling. Bake it on the day you plan to serve it for the best texture.
Check out this recipe
How to Arrange a Christmas Cookie Tray
- Choose your tray. Use a food-safe platter, board, or shallow box. Line gift boxes with food-safe parchment before adding treats.
- Place the larger pieces first. Arrange cookies and sturdy bars in small groups, leaving room for the smaller treats.
- Fill the gaps. Add clusters, marshmallows, and bite-size bark pieces between the groups. Use paper baking cups for sticky or delicate pieces.
- Separate strong flavors. Keep peppermint treats in their own section or cups. Store them separately before assembling so the mint doesn’t flavor everything else.
- Add chilled desserts last. Keep cannoli and bars with yogurt or cream cheese frosting refrigerated until serving. Put out smaller portions and replenish from the refrigerator as needed.
If you’re making the Santa board or pastry tree, give it its own space on the table and arrange the smaller trays around it. This leaves room for people to reach the cookies without crowding the centerpiece.
Make-Ahead and Storage Tips
Choose your recipes before setting a prep schedule. Each has different cooling, setting, and storage needs, so check the full recipe before deciding how far ahead to make it.
- Ahead of time: Prepare the date bark and truffles, then store them as directed. Freeze cookie dough only where the individual recipe provides instructions.
- The day before: Bake bars, let them cool completely, and frost as directed. Refrigerate yogurt- and cream cheese-frosted bars. Keep different types of treats in separate containers until assembly.
- The day of serving: Fill cannoli shells, bake the puff pastry tree, and arrange the tray. Add crushed candy canes and colored sprinkles close to serving to help prevent color bleeding into the frosting.
Plain cookies and refrigerated desserts need different handling. Keep dairy-filled or yogurt- and cream cheese-frosted treats chilled until serving. FDA food-storage guidance recommends limiting perishable foods to two hours at room temperature, or one hour above 90°F. Serve small portions and keep the rest cold.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many cookies should I plan per person?
As a starting estimate, plan on three or four small cookies or bite-size treats per person when other desserts are available. For 10 guests, that’s about 30–40 small pieces in total. Adjust for cookie size, other food being served, and whether guests will take some home.
Which treats should I choose for a gift box?
Start with sturdy cookies and treats whose storage directions fit the way you’ll deliver the box. Pack delicate marshmallows, sticky bark, and peppermint treats separately. If you include something that needs refrigeration, keep it cold during transport and tell the recipient to refrigerate it promptly.
Can I make a gluten-free Christmas cookie tray?
Yes, by choosing recipes and ingredients that meet that need. Check flour blends, oats, protein powders, chocolate, candy, crackers, and toppings rather than relying on the recipe name alone. Prepare and pack those treats separately from gluten-containing cookies to avoid cross-contact.
How do I keep crisp cookies from getting soft?
Store crisp cookies separately from soft cookies, frosted bars, and other moist treats until you’re ready to assemble the tray. Keep any refrigerated desserts in their own containers. Arrange everything close to serving rather than storing the finished mixed tray for several days.
Which recipes would you put on your Christmas cookie tray? Leave a comment and let me know what you’re making!
Join the Newsletter
& Receive My Free Guide, Bake Better: The Sprinkled Cakery’s Essential Healthy Swaps